Skip to content

VBAC Blog Carnival: Why is VBAC a Vital Option?

As the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Consensus Development Conference on Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (VBAC) gets underway this morning, we bring you our first-ever ICAN Blog Carnival. We have invited bloggers to submit entries on the topic, “Why is VBAC a Vital Option?” and they have answered. Thanks to all the bloggers featured below for your passionate and insightful entries.

Allison’s story on The Unnecessarian is all too familiar to many women – pressured into a cesarean for a “big baby”, assured that VBAC will be supported, only to have the rug pulled out from under you at the last minute and instead “agreeing” to a repeat cesarean (but was there really a choice?). What of the evidence supporting VBAC’s safety? What of the rights of women to refuse unwanted surgery? These are the questions Allison’s story raises and other bloggers have sought to address.

VBAC: What about rights and choice?

Sheridan at Enjoy Birth illustrates the quandry faced by VBACing women with an analogy to choosing whether to travel by boat or by plane. Henci Goer at Science and Sensibility discusses the perils of viewing VBAC from a “preference” perspective as opposed to a right.  Janelle at Birth Sense shares the provider’s perspective, including concerns about malpractice insurance, threat of lawsuits, and time constraints, but also argues that providers must stand up for evidence-based guidelines. Courtroom Mama dissects excuses made by hospitals for not allowing VBACs that demonstrate the paternalism behind VBAC  bans. Simone at the International Childbirth Education Association (ICEA) blog shares two VBAC stories, illustrating that, while VBAC “success” is not a guarantee, it is nevertheless a woman’s choice to try and no one should stand in her way. However, as Rachel at Frum doula and Kayce at Hearts and Hands Services argue, many women do not even know they have the choice to VBAC or are misinformed about the risks of VBAC vs. repeat cesarean. Finally, Gina at the Feminist Breeder sums it all up: access to VBAC is fundamentally a human right.

VBAC: Good for Moms and Babies

So much of the focus around VBAC is about the increased risk of uterine rupture due to the cesarean scar. While this risk is real, several of our bloggers point out that VBAC is also protective, of both mothers and babies. Melissa of Melissa’s Space, a VBAC mother herself, discusses how VBAC actually protects mothers and babies from the risks and consequences of surgery. Similarly, Willow at Willow’s Rest, an OB nurse and VBAC mama, shares her own experience of the hidden costs of cesarean for mothers.

Still further, some of our carnival  bloggers assert that increasing VBAC’s availability can help solve major issues facing maternity care in the U.S. Robin at Birth Activist discusses how increasing VBAC could lower the maternal mortality rate.  Heather and Jessie at ICAN of the Twin Cities blog posit that VBACs are vital to reversing the rising cesarean rate. Kim at Tea and Devons states that supporting VBACs will help ensure that cesareans occur only when truly necessary. Finally, Kristen at Birthing Beautiful Ideas suggests that if the wealth of evidence surrounding the safety of VBAC is not persuasive enough, perhaps providers and hospitals that refuse to support VBAC should face regulatory pressure or incentives to severely limit the number of primary cesareans they perform.


  1. Laura Gilkey says:

    Hey ladies…this is a GREAT collection. Yesterday, I posted on the upcoming Florida state hearing to permanently ban VBACs in birth centers. A little too late to enter the carnival, but I hope you’ll read it here. Great work to all of you!

  2. [...] Comments VBAC Blog Carnival: Why is VBAC a Vital Option? | ICAN Blog on VBAC is VitalJenny on Cesarean RecoveryMelinda on CDC Releases Home Birth [...]

  3. [...] UPDATE:Read the VBAC Blog Carnival here! [...]

  4. Amber says:

    This are ALL FABULOUS – can you make sure that the presenters are getting all of these important posts? After 2 c-sections, I had to fight hard for my VBA2C – I ended up having a homebirth because of lack of support. Last month, I had my 2nd fabulous homebirth VBA2C. It can be done! How dare any hospital or doctor “ban” VBAC? No one has the right to force me into an unnecessary surgery.
    Please e-mail these blog posts to the conference moderator and coordinators and ask that they distribute them to the “decision makers” – of course, the woman should be the decision maker, but, apparently when it comes to birth, it doesn’t work that way:

  5. [...] They are right: there is an active blog community on the internet. And we’ve been “actively blogging” about VBAC for several weeks now. The blogging effort was coordinated, too. The International Cesarean Awareness Network pulled together an amazing collection of links to posts all over the internet on the topic of “VBAC as a Vital Option.” [...]

  6. [...] « VBAC Blog Carnival: Why is VBAC a Vital Option? [...]

  7. [...] official response on the draft consensus statement and read (or re-read) last week’s VBAC blog carnival. Also, check out Stand and Deliver and BirthAction Blog for links to many of the other birth [...]